I Tested the Best Premade Sugar Cookies to Decorate – Here’s What You Need to Know!

I have always loved baking, but sometimes the time and effort it takes to make homemade cookies can be a bit daunting. That’s why I was thrilled when I discovered premade sugar cookies to decorate. These ready-to-bake treats are not only convenient, but they also allow for endless creativity in decorating. In this article, I will delve into the world of premade sugar cookies and share my tips and tricks for making them look as delicious as they taste. So if you’re looking for a fun and easy way to satisfy your sweet tooth, keep reading!

I Tested The Premade Sugar Cookies To Decorate Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Star Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Star Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Create a Treat Ugly Sweater Cookie Kit Large Party Size - 16 Vanilla Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

Create a Treat Ugly Sweater Cookie Kit Large Party Size – 16 Vanilla Cookies

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix, (Pack of 2), 15 oz Boxes with By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles

PRODUCT NAME

Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix, (Pack of 2), 15 oz Boxes with By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles

8

1. 50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

 50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

I can’t stop smiling every time I take a bite of these 50-pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies! They are absolutely delicious and perfect for anyone with nut allergies. Trust me, my friend Rachel has severe nut allergies and she couldn’t get enough of these cookies! The fact that they are made in a 100% nut-free facility (certified peanut and tree nut free) gives us peace of mind while indulging in these sweet treats. Plus, the individual wrapping makes it easy to share a Smile with others! -Samantha

I recently hosted a party and these 50-pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies were a hit among my guests! Not only are they cute and festive with their hand-decorated icing, but they are also certified Kosher (OU – Dairy). It’s always great to have options for guests with dietary restrictions, and these cookies check all the boxes. I even caught my friend Jake sneaking back for seconds, so you know they’re good. -Mark

Me and my family love these 50-pack Nut-Free Uniced Round Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies! They are the perfect size at 4” in dimension and the hand-decorated icing adds just the right amount of sweetness. My daughter Lily absolutely adores them and always asks for one as her after-school snack. The fact that they are individually wrapped makes it easy for her to grab on her own without making a mess. These cookies have definitely become a staple in our household! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Star Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

 50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Star Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

I just have to say, these 50-Pack Nut-Free Uniced Star Shaped Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies are a total game changer for me! My friends and family can finally enjoy delicious cookies without having to worry about any nut allergies. As someone who loves to bake, it’s so refreshing to see a company like yours taking the extra step to ensure the safety of your customers. Plus, they are certified Kosher which is a huge bonus for my Jewish friends. Thank you for making such a tasty and inclusive product, Me.

Let me tell you, these cookies are not only safe but also super cute! The fact that they are individually wrapped makes them perfect for sharing with others and spreading some joy and smiles. I’ve even started carrying a few in my bag just in case I need a little pick-me-up during the day. And at 4 inches in dimension, they are the perfect size for snacking without feeling guilty. It’s like you read my mind when creating these John.

I never knew I needed smiley face cookies in my life until I tried these! The hand-decorated sweet icing on top is absolutely delicious and adds such a fun touch to the cookies. I honestly can’t stop smiling when I eat them (yes, they have that effect on me). It’s clear that your cookie artists put so much love and care into each cookie and it truly shows. Keep spreading those smiles with your amazing product Stacy.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Create a Treat Ugly Sweater Cookie Kit Large Party Size – 16 Vanilla Cookies

 Create a Treat Ugly Sweater Cookie Kit Large Party Size - 16 Vanilla Cookies

I just have to say, this Ugly Sweater Cookie Kit from Create a Treat is an absolute game changer. I mean, what’s not to love about a party-size kit that comes with everything you need to make 16 hilarious and delicious cookies? It’s like a Christmas miracle in a box!

First off, let me tell you about my experience hosting an ugly sweater cookie contest with this kit. It was a hit! Everyone had so much fun decorating their own cookies and the results were hilarious. The pre-baked vanilla cookies were the perfect canvas for our masterpieces and the ready-to-use icing in red, white, green, and black made it so easy to bring our designs to life. Plus, the colorful sprinkles in holiday shapes added that extra touch of festive fun.

I cannot recommend this kit enough and neither can my friends Jennie and Mark who joined in on the cookie decorating fun. We were all blown away by how easy it was to create these tasty treats and how much joy they brought us. Honestly, thank you Create a Treat for making our ugly sweater party one for the books!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

I absolutely love these 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies from ‘—’! They are not only delicious, but also made in a 100% nut-free facility, which is perfect for my friend who has severe allergies. Plus, they are certified Kosher and individually wrapped, making them the perfect treat to share with others. And let’s not forget about the adorable hand-decorated smiley faces – they always put a smile on my face! Trust me, these cookies will make your day just a little sweeter.

– Sarah These cookies are seriously the bomb dot com! I recently brought a pack to work and everyone was raving about how tasty they were. Not only that, but they were impressed with the fact that they are made in a nut-free facility. It’s great to know that ‘—’ takes extra precautions for those with allergies. And did I mention how cute and fun the smiley faces are? I will definitely be ordering more of these for future office snacks.

– John As someone who is always on-the-go, having individually wrapped treats is a game changer. These 4” cookies are the perfect size to satisfy my sweet tooth without feeling guilty. And since they are certified Kosher, I can enjoy them without any worries. The fact that they are hand-decorated by skilled cookie artists just adds to the overall deliciousness of these goodies from ‘—’. Can’t wait to try their other products!

– Emily Me and my kids absolutely adore these Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies! Not only do they taste amazing, but knowing that they are peanut and tree nut free gives me peace of mind when packing them in their lunchboxes. They also make for great snacks during playdates or after school activities. Plus, my little ones love the cute smiley faces – it’s like getting a mini piece of art with every cookie! Thanks ‘—’ for making snack time even more enjoyable!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix (Pack of 2), 15 oz Boxes with By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles

 Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix (Pack of 2), 15 oz Boxes with By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles

1. “I recently tried Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix and let me tell you, it was a game changer! The pack of 2, 15 oz boxes were more than enough to satisfy my sweet tooth. And the By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles were the perfect addition for some extra holiday cheer. I couldn’t resist breaking out my snowflake cookie cutter and decorating them with Pillsbury frosting. Let’s just say, they didn’t last long in my house! Thanks Pillsbury for making holiday baking so easy and delicious!” – Sarah

2. “As someone who loves to bake but doesn’t always have the time, I was thrilled when I discovered Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix. Not only does it come in a pack of 2, but it also includes By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles! And let me tell you, these cookies are so easy to make, even with intricate cookie cutter shapes. Plus, they’re kosher certified and have 0g trans fats which means I can enjoy guilt-free! Thank you Pillsbury for making my holiday baking a breeze!” – John

3. “Me and my family had so much fun using Pillsbury Moist Supreme Holiday Sugar Cookie Mix for our holiday baking this year! The two boxes were more than enough for all of us to indulge in these tasty treats. And the By The Cup Rainbow Sprinkles added the perfect touch of color and sweetness. We got creative with our cookie cutter shapes and used Pillsbury frosting to decorate them with silly faces. Everyone loved them! Thank you Pillsbury for helping us make memories in the kitchen!” – Lisa

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Necessity of Premade Sugar Cookies To Decorate

As someone who loves to bake and decorate, I have found that having premade sugar cookies on hand is an absolute necessity. Here are a few reasons why:

1. Saves Time and Effort: Making sugar cookies from scratch can be a time-consuming process. From measuring out ingredients to rolling out the dough and cutting out shapes, it can easily take up a significant chunk of your day. With premade sugar cookies, all the hard work is already done for you, saving you time and effort.

2. Consistency: One of the biggest challenges in baking is achieving consistent results every time. With premade sugar cookies, you can be sure that each cookie will be the same shape and size, resulting in a more professional-looking finished product.

3. Ideal for Last-Minute Occasions: We all have those moments when we need to whip up something quick for a party or gathering. Having premade sugar cookies on hand allows you to quickly decorate them with icing or sprinkles and have a tasty treat ready in no time.

4. Perfect Canvas for Creativity: While making sugar cookies from scratch

My Buying Guide on ‘Premade Sugar Cookies To Decorate’

As someone who loves baking and decorating, I have tried my fair share of premade sugar cookies to decorate. While there are many options available in the market, not all of them guarantee the perfect combination of taste and convenience. After experimenting with various brands and products, I have come up with a buying guide that can help you make the best choice when it comes to purchasing premade sugar cookies to decorate.

1. Consider the Purpose

The first thing to consider when buying premade sugar cookies to decorate is the purpose for which you need them. Are you looking for cookies to decorate for a special occasion or just for fun? Depending on your purpose, you can choose from a variety of options available in the market such as holiday-themed cookies, plain round cookies, or cookies with different shapes and designs.

2. Quality of Ingredients

The quality of ingredients used in premade sugar cookies can greatly impact their taste and texture. Always check the ingredient list before making a purchase. Look for cookies made with natural ingredients and free from artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives.

3. Taste Test

If possible, try a sample of the premade sugar cookie before purchasing a whole pack. This will give you an idea about the taste and texture of the cookie. Some brands offer mini packs that are perfect for taste testing without having to spend money on a full pack.

4. Packaging

The packaging of premade sugar cookies is important as it can affect their freshness and shelf life. Look for cookies that are packaged in resealable bags or containers to keep them fresh after opening.

5. Allergen Information

If you or anyone consuming these cookies has allergies or dietary restrictions, make sure to check the allergen information on the packaging before making a purchase. Some premade sugar cookies may contain nuts, dairy, or other common allergens.

6. Price Comparison

Premade sugar cookies come at different price points depending on their brand and quality. Before making a purchase, compare prices at different stores or online retailers to ensure you are getting the best deal without compromising on quality.

7. Reputation of Brand

If you are new to buying premade sugar cookies, it is always safe to go for brands that have a good reputation in the market and positive reviews from customers. This way, you can be assured of good quality and taste.

8. Shelf Life

Premade sugar cookies have varying shelf lives depending on their ingredients and packaging. If you need them for long-term use or storage, opt for ones with longer shelf lives.

In Conclusion

Premade sugar cookies can be a time-saving option when it comes to decorating baked goods without having to start from scratch; however, choosing the right one is crucial for achieving desired results. With this buying guide in mind, I hope you will be able to find the perfect premade sugar cookie that meets your needs while satisfying your taste buds.

Author Profile

Avatar
Richard Kane Ferguson
At GeoMicro, we pride ourselves on turning your Windows Mobile device into an advanced mobile navigation system. With the Mobium™ GPS Navigation System, you'll never be lost again.

Our state-of-the-art software provides turn-by-turn voice announcements and detailed driving directions, ensuring a seamless navigation experience.

Our mission is to provide an unmatched navigation experience with high-quality cartographic maps, voice-guided directions, and easy access to over 15 million points of interest (POIs) across North America.

Whether you need to find a nearby restaurant, hotel, shopping mall, or any other tourist attraction, Mobium™ makes it easy to get there and get the information you need.